Starbucks and Tim Hortons Face Discrimination Complaint in Mexico Over Plant Milk Surcharges

Share

Starbucks

@ Starbucks

Mercy For Animals has filed a formal complaint against Starbucks and Tim Hortons with Mexico’s National Council to Prevent Discrimination (Conapred). The group argues that the extra fee both chains charge for plant-based milk in Mexico treats some customers unfairly. Both companies have already scrapped the same surcharge in the US and Canada.

According to the animal protection nonprofit, coffee chains in Mexico still add between MXN 11 and MXN 15 to drinks made with soy, almond or oat milk. It says the “arbitrary” extra fees penalize people for their ethical or ideological convictions and break with the fair-pricing principles the same companies already follow in other countries.

The filing is part of Mala Leche, a campaign Mercy For Animals Latin America launched in early November. In Spanish, mala leche means bad faith or spite.

Mercy for Animals
@ Mercy for Animals

Same drink, different price

Starbucks removed the non-dairy upcharge at its company-operated stores in the US and Canada in November 2024. It had already dropped the fee in the UK, Germany and France. Tim Hortons ended its Canadian surcharge in January 2025 and then confirmed the change for its US locations. Mercy For Animals says the chains have also dropped the fee in some Latin American markets but did not say which ones.

Starbucks stores in Mexico are run by Mexican restaurant operator Alsea, which renewed its licence agreements with Starbucks in May. The deal lets Alsea operate the brand until 2046, as reported by Expansión.

“Choosing a plant-based drink should not translate into a penalty for the wallet. When the same drink costs more solely because of the type of milk chosen, we are dealing with exclusionary treatment,” said Fernando Gallart, executive director of Mercy For Animals Latin America.

Mercy for Animals
@ Mercy for Animals

Mexican chains also named

The campaign also calls on Mexican chains Café Punta del Cielo, Cielito Querido Café and Caffenio to remove the surcharge. Mercy For Animals says it will publicly track which companies drop the fee. Its campaign website lets consumers send a one-click email to company executives or tag the brands on social media.

The organisation says the fee also holds back the uptake of lower-impact drinks. It cites a 2018 study by Poore and Nemecek, which found that soy drink produces on average 69% fewer greenhouse gas emissions than cow’s milk and uses up to 21 times less freshwater. Mercy For Animals also cites a 2019 estimate from the Mexican Social Security Institute (IMSS) that around 83% of Mexico’s population is lactose intolerant. On that basis, it argues that millions of consumers pay a premium to buy a drink they can digest.

“It is time for the major chains to eliminate this double standard and allow consumers in Mexico to exercise their freedom of choice, as they do in other countries, without additional charges,” said Gallart.

 

We are passionate about food!

Gourmet Cooking Magazine is an online destination for people who love food, cooking, and the culture that surrounds it. We cover recipes, culinary trends, ingredient spotlights, chef stories, kitchen techniques, nutrition insights, and food news from around the world.

You May Also Like