5 Brown Sugar Shaken Espresso Recipes to Make at Home

Share

Did you click to this page because somewhere along the way, a brown sugar shaken espresso grabbed you by the taste buds and never let go?

Same here. Hi. Welcome to the club.

No? Not you? First of all, how is it possible.

Second, here is what it’s all about. Bold espresso gets shaken hard with brown sugar syrup and a whisper of cinnamon until it’s frothy and ice-cold. Then it’s topped with a silky pour of oat milk. It’s sweet but not cloying. It’s strong but not scary. It looks gorgeous in a glass, and it tastes like a cozy sweater went to the gym.

The problem is, my coffee shop addictions were getting expensive. So I did what any reasonable, slightly obsessed person would do. I started making them at home. Then I started tweaking them. Then I started tweaking the tweaks. Dozens of batches, one very overworked cocktail shaker, and more caffeine than I’d care to admit later, I’ve landed on five recipes I genuinely can’t stop making.

Some are faithful to the classic. Some take it in delicious new directions. All of them are easy enough to pull off before your first meeting, even if you’re still half asleep.

So grab your shaker (or a mason jar, I don’t judge), and let’s get shaking.

Best Brown Sugar Shaken Espresso Recipes

Every recipe here starts the same way: espresso, brown sugar, cinnamon and ice, shaken hard, with milk poured on top. The shake chills the hot espresso fast and makes the light foam that sits on top. Each one comes with the full ingredient list and the video to make it from.

Brown Sugar Shaken Espresso with Oat Milk Cold Foam

Brown sugar shaken espresso with oat milk cold foam is the one I make from scratch. Its video is also the most watched of the ones I found on YouTube, with nearly a million views. All those views, plus the homemade syrup, are why I tried it. The syrup starts with your own brown sugar: plain cane sugar mashed with molasses, then melted on the stove with water, cinnamon and vanilla. You get about a cup of thick syrup, enough for a lot of drinks. Store-bought brown sugar still works if you have no molasses, but homemade tastes better.

I shake a double shot hard with the syrup and ice, strain it over fresh ice, and top it with a spiced oat milk cold foam. Cold foam is just cold milk frothed until it’s thick enough to spoon on top. The recipe makes one tall glass, about 12 ounces, and it tastes a lot more like brown sugar and molasses than the Starbucks drink. I make this one every morning now.

Making your own syrup takes time, so save this recipe for a morning when you have time to make syrup. Shake gently for a few seconds first, so the cold shaker seals and doesn’t leak.

Ingredients

  • 200 g cane sugar
  • 30 g molasses
  • about 175 g water
  • 1 tsp (3 g) cinnamon
  • 1/2 tsp vanilla paste
  • 8 oz cold oat milk
  • pinch of cinnamon (for the foam)
  • dash of vanilla paste (for the foam)
  • pinch of sugar (for the foam)
  • ice
  • 30 g brown sugar syrup (or to taste)
  • double shot of espresso
  • cinnamon to garnish
brown sugar shaken espresso recipe

Easy Copycat Brown Sugar Oat Milk Shaken Espresso

Brown sugar oat milk shaken espresso made this way is my quick weekday copy of the Starbucks drink. Under its video on YouTube, I kept seeing comments from people who made it and said it tastes like Starbucks, so I had to try it. The syrup is a small batch that only gets a quick simmer on the stove, so it stays thin and mixes right into the cold drink.

A Nespresso double shot pod gives you two shots instead of the usual three in a Starbucks grande, and that’s plenty for me. You shake the shots with the syrup, a dash of cinnamon and ice, then pour oat milk on top. One drink takes about ten minutes. I get the best foam when I pour everything from the shaker into the glass, foam and ice too, instead of straining it over fresh ice.

Stir in the vanilla after the syrup comes off the heat so the vanilla keeps more of its flavor. If the drink is too sweet for you, use 3 tablespoons of brown sugar instead of four. Cold brew or instant espresso work in place of the shots, and almond milk works if you’re out of oat milk.

Ingredients

  • 4 tbsp brown sugar
  • 3 tbsp water
  • dash of cinnamon
  • 1 tsp vanilla extract
  • 2 shots of espresso (one Nespresso double shot pod)
  • about 2 pumps of the brown sugar syrup
  • ice
  • cinnamon powder
  • oat milk
copycat brown sugar oat milk shaken espresso

Low Carb Brown Sugar Shaken Espresso

Cutting carbs is the reason this brown sugar shaken espresso stays on my list: it’s made with sugar-free syrup and almond milk. The brown sugar taste comes from a small spoon of blackstrap molasses stirred into homemade sugar-free vanilla syrup. A store-bought brown sugar substitute works too if you have one.

That syrup goes over ice and unsweetened almond milk with a double shot and a dash of cinnamon. One drink takes about five minutes, and it comes out strong and only lightly sweet. I like this drink a lot more shaken with the ice than stirred in the glass, because the shake is what gives you the foam.

Keep the molasses to about a teaspoon, since it still adds a few carbs. Unsweetened cashew milk makes the drink creamier and is still low in carbs, but skip oat milk, which has too many carbs.

Ingredients

  • ice
  • unsweetened almond milk
  • 1 shot homemade sugar-free vanilla syrup
  • about 1 tsp blackstrap molasses (or a brown sugar substitute)
  • 2 shots of espresso
  • dash of cinnamon
low carb brown sugar shaken espresso

Brown Sugar Shaken Espresso with Homemade Oat Milk

In this all-homemade brown sugar shaken espresso, even the oat milk is made from scratch, with just oats and water. That homemade oat milk is why I made this drink. Blend the oats with very cold water, but only for a short time, or the milk turns slimy. Then strain it through a nut milk bag, and your milk is ready.

The syrup is even simpler: brown sugar, water and vanilla stirred on the stove until it thickens a little. I give three shots a hard shake with the syrup, cinnamon and ice, then pour the fresh oat milk on top. The recipe makes one big drink. I let the shots cool a little before they hit the ice, because hot espresso melts it fast and the drink turns watery. On a busy day, store-bought oat milk is the easy shortcut.

Ingredients

  • 4 tbsp brown sugar
  • 2 tbsp water
  • 1/2 tsp vanilla extract
  • 50 g oats
  • 500 g water
  • 3 shots of espresso
  • 1/2 tsp cinnamon
  • ice
brown sugar shaken espresso with homemade oat milk

5-Ingredient Brown Sugar Shaken Espresso in a Jar

Brown sugar shaken espresso in a jar takes me two minutes. This jar drink has five ingredients and no syrup to cook, which makes it my pick for busy mornings. The brown sugar and cinnamon melt right into a hot shot of espresso in a glass jar, then ice and oat milk go in, the lid goes on, and a hard shake makes the foam.

The jar makes one small drink, and you don’t need a shaker or an espresso machine. A few spoons of strong coffee from an AeroPress or a French press work in place of the shot. I get more foam when I shake the espresso, sugar and ice first and pour the milk in after. For a bigger glass, use 3/4 cup oat milk and a few more ice cubes, or just double everything.

Ingredients

  • 2 tsp brown sugar
  • 1/16 to 1/8 tsp cinnamon
  • 1 shot espresso (or 2 to 4 tbsp strong brewed coffee)
  • 6 ice cubes
  • 1/2 cup oat milk
brown sugar shaken espresso in a jar

Brown Sugar Shaken Espresso Questions

Here are a few quick answers before you start shaking.

What Is in the Starbucks Brown Sugar Shaken Espresso?

The shop drink is Blonde espresso shaken with brown sugar syrup and cinnamon, poured over ice, then topped with oat milk. A grande usually has three shots. For the closest match at home, use a Blonde roast, and go with three shots if you want your drink as strong as the Starbucks one.

How Long Does Brown Sugar Syrup Keep?

Brown sugar syrup keeps about two weeks in a closed jar in the fridge. That goes for every cooked syrup on this list, thick or thin. Make a double batch and you have syrup ready for a lot of mornings. If the syrup turns cloudy or smells off, toss it.

Can I Make It Without an Espresso Machine?

Yes. A moka pot on the stove makes strong, espresso-style coffee, and a Nespresso pod works too. For instant espresso or instant coffee, mix it with only about a quarter cup of water so it’s as strong as a double shot. Whatever you use, make the coffee strong, or it gets lost under the ice and milk.

Is It Cheaper to Make at Home?

A grande at Starbucks runs about six to eight dollars, depending on where you live. At home it’s mostly coffee, a spoon of sugar and some milk, so once you have those in the kitchen, you save on every drink you make.

Make the quick thin syrup when you’re in a hurry, and the thick molasses syrup when you want a stronger brown sugar taste. I make the jar drink when I’m half awake, and the one with oat milk cold foam when I want my kitchen to feel like a coffee shop. Pick the drink that fits your morning and shake it hard.

The post 5 Brown Sugar Shaken Espresso Recipes to Make at Home appeared first on Fast Food Menu Prices.

 

We are passionate about food!

Gourmet Cooking Magazine is an online destination for people who love food, cooking, and the culture that surrounds it. We cover recipes, culinary trends, ingredient spotlights, chef stories, kitchen techniques, nutrition insights, and food news from around the world.

You May Also Like