What to Do With All Those Apples (Beyond the Pie)

You come home from the orchard with more apples than any reasonable person needs, and then the question becomes what to actually do with them. Pie is the obvious answer. It is also the least interesting one available.

Apples are the most versatile fruit of the season, and they work as readily in a pan sauce for pork as they do under a crumble topping. Here is which variety to reach for, which spices pull the most out of them, and everything worth making beyond the obvious.

How do I know which apples to buy?

The choice matters more than most recipes let on, because apples fall into two broad camps and they behave very differently under heat.

Firm and tart apples hold their shape through a long bake. Granny Smith is the reference point, along with Braeburn, Honeycrisp, and Pink Lady. These are what you want in a pie, a galette, or anything where distinct pieces of fruit are the point rather than a uniform texture.

Soft and sweet apples break down into something closer to sauce. McIntosh, Gala, Fuji, and Golden Delicious fall here. These are the apples for apple butter, applesauce, and anything you intend to puree or mash anyway.

The Two-Apple Rule: For pie specifically, use both. A mix of firm-tart and soft-sweet gives you fruit that holds its shape alongside fruit that collapses into the gaps, which is how you avoid the hollow dome that forms when a pie is built entirely from Granny Smiths. Two parts firm to one part soft is a reliable starting ratio.

What spices actually belong with apples?

Cinnamon is the default, and for good reason, but it is a broad category rather than a single flavor, and the distinction is worth understanding.

Supreme Saigon Cinnamon is the strongest and sweetest of the cinnamons, high in the volatile oil that gives cinnamon its bite. It stands up to a long bake without fading, which is why it belongs in a pie that spends an hour in the oven.

Cinnamon Sugar blends Ceylon and Indonesian cinnamons, the Ceylon bringing a citrus brightness that keeps it from reading as one flat note. This is the finishing option, sprinkled over a pie before it bakes or onto sliced apples directly.

Beyond cinnamon

Mt. Baker Chai Seasoning is the most underrated pairing here. It is cinnamon-based but salt-free, with cardamom and a licorice edge that gives apple something more complex than sweetness to work against.

Spiced Apple Bake takes the decision out of your hands entirely. It is a full mix, sweet baking spice with a subtle vanilla note and enough salt to keep the sweetness in check, built to go straight into a crisp with four chopped apples, oats, brown sugar, and butter.

On the savory side, Rubbed Sage is the classic partner, which is what makes our Apple-Sage Jelly recipe work as well as it does. Fennel, thyme, and black pepper all belong with apple too, particularly alongside pork.

What’s the best recipe for an apple pie?

Grated Apple Pie came to us from a customer in Oklahoma City, and the technique is what makes it worth your attention. The apples are grated rather than sliced, then tossed with sugar, flour, Supreme Saigon Cinnamon, and salt and left to sit for fifteen minutes while the sugar draws the juice out. Melted butter and an egg get folded in, pecans and Cinnamon Sugar go on top, and it bakes at 400 before dropping to 350 for another hour. What comes out is closer to a custard than a conventional slice.

Honey Rose Apple Pie goes the other direction entirely, thin apple slices arranged in overlapping rings so the finished pie looks like a rose. More patience than difficulty, and it is the one to make when the pie itself is meant to be the centerpiece.

If a full pie feels like more commitment than the evening deserves, Apple Pie Bites gets you most of the way there in individual portions, and Chai Apple Turnovers uses Mt. Baker Chai instead of straight cinnamon for something a little more interesting.

Going beyond the pie: Galettes, crisps, crumbles

A galette is a pie with none of the anxiety, no crimped edges, no lattice, just fruit on pastry with the sides folded over. Easy Salted Caramel Apple Galette uses puff pastry, Pumpkin Pie Spice on the apples, and finishes with salted caramel sauce and a crunch of Whiskey Barrel Smoked Sugar and Salt.

Apple and Brie Galette runs the same format somewhere more savory, and it works as an appetizer as readily as a dessert.

Danish Apple Squares is the best recipe to make for a crowd, baked in a sheet pan and cut into bars, and Baked Apples is the one that barely qualifies as a recipe at all, cored apples, filling, oven, done.

And finally, our recipe for Baked Apple Donuts gets you apple cider-donut flavor without a fryer, finished with Spiced Vanilla Bean Sugar.

What can you do with 10 pounds of apples?
Make apple butter.

This is always the answer to the orchard problem. Apple butter uses a genuinely large quantity of fruit, requires almost no technique, and keeps for two weeks in the refrigerator.

Chai Apple Butter takes ten large apples, brown sugar, lemon juice, Mt. Baker Chai, vanilla bean paste, and Mayan Sea Salt, and asks you to do nothing but stir occasionally over five to six hours in a slow cooker. Mash it for texture or blend it smooth.

Spiced Apple Butter is the more traditional version if chai is not the direction you want, and Chai-Spiced Apples stops short of butter entirely, leaving the fruit in recognizable pieces for spooning over ice cream or oatmeal.

What are some savory recipes using apples?

This is where apple earns the versatile label, and where most people never think to use it.

Pork is the natural pairing, and Pork Tenderloin with Apple and Onion Pan Sauce is the clearest demonstration. Apple and onion cook down in the pan drippings into a sauce that goes sweet and savory at once. Grilled Pork Chops with Savory Fruit Compote takes the same principle to the grill.

Our recipe for Red Wine Grilled Pork and Apples is more ambitious, and the sauce is the reason to make it. Red wine, maple syrup, and soy sauce reduce with Supreme Saigon Cinnamon, ground rosemary, and Park Hill Maple & Spice down to a third of their original volume while the pork grills. Gala apple slices go on the grill for two minutes a side, the pork rests on top of them, and the reduction goes over everything.

Truffle Parm Apple Grilled Cheese is the one that convinces people. Fig jam and Black Truffle Parmesan Seasoning go into a buttered baguette with thin apple slices and melting cheese, pressed panini-style until the crust is deeply golden.

Roasted Delicata Squash with Apple & Onion Sauce pairs apple with squash and a Four Mushroom Umami Blend reduction, and our recipe for Apple-Ginger Wild Rice works diced apple into a grain side where the sweetness cuts through the earthiness of the rice.

Two more worth knowing: Cinnamon-Apple Baked Beans puts real apple and cinnamon where most recipes settle for brown sugar, and Maple Roasted Root Vegetables and Quinoa Salad uses diced green apple raw, against roasted sweet potato and a maple vinaigrette.

How can I make apple cider? Hot or cold?

Mulled Apple Cider is the whole reason mulling spices exist. Fresh cider, a spice bag, gentle heat, and the smell fills the house before anyone has poured a cup. Three tablespoons of mulling spices per gallon is the ratio.

Wassail is the same idea scaled for a party, with brandy, madeira, or rum if the occasion calls for it, and Sweet Potato Cider Bisque proves cider belongs in savory cooking too, where it does the work a stock alone cannot.

And a recipe that came from our own spice stores: Apple Pie Moonshine. Apple cider, Spiced Vanilla Bean Sugar, and an Indonesian cinnamon stick simmer for five minutes, then cool completely before the moonshine goes in. Drinkable immediately, noticeably better after a day in the refrigerator.

There’s no such thing as picking too many apples.

The good news about buying too many apples is that almost nothing here requires them to be perfect. Apple butter wants the ones going soft.

A crisp does not care whether the slices are even. Pie is the only thing on this list with real standards, and even that forgives more than people expect.

Browse more fall flavors →

More of the season: Welcome to Fall, Behind the Seasoning: Pumpkin Pie Spice, and Behind the Seasoning: Mulling Spices.